The Big Picture
Students told us they are busy, trying hard, and want to be understood. They asked their teachers for work that feels purposeful, clear directions, help when they need it, and respect. Many also thanked their teachers for impacting their lives.
Most of what they asked for is practical and within reach.
-
This is the most common response shared by students. MIHS students say homework from all their classes piles up in one night, and weekends get treated as free time for big projects. They also say it crowds out sports, extracurriculars, sleep, family commitments, and personal goals. High schoolers described hours of homework each night and stress about workload. Specific examples include "4 hours of homework everyday" and "15 pages of history textbook a night." One student who wants to be a musician says they have no time to practice. Several note that teachers seem unaware of what other classes assign. Some say several large projects land in the same week. Middle schoolers asked for more in-class work time, flexible deadlines, and no big weekend projects. Many said teachers don't realize what other classes assign.
-
Students find long lectures, packets, repeated worksheets, and videos boring or unhelpful. They asked for hands-on projects, visuals, movement, fresh activities, and teachers who enjoy the work. Many want to know why they are learning something and how it connects to real life. High schoolers said teaching style affects how excited they are to learn.
-
Students described exhaustion and pressure from peers, parents, teachers, and themselves. One response ties the pressure to Mercer Island's culture of high achievement. Several link the stress directly to workload. Some said they feel anxious or overwhelmed and describe hidden struggles. A few described crying at school or wanting to skip classes.
-
"I'm trying my best" came up again and again in the responses. Students say a low grade doesn't mean they aren't trying. They point out that test scores can miss real understanding, that subjective rubrics feel unfair, and that grades don't reflect intelligence when life outside school is hard.
-
Students say they learn at different paces and that how well something is explained matters. Some feel teachers should teach rather than hand over a worksheet and expect self-teaching. Others mention needing breaks, fidgeting, writing better than speaking, and asking many questions because they're working to understand. A few say they'd be more motivated and engaged if teaching style or responses to questions changed.
Students learn at different speeds and need clear explanations with examples. Several said they ask many questions because they are working to understand, and that being discouraged shuts them down. They asked teachers to check in without waiting for questions, break down assignments, and help them work through a problem rather than rereading it. Some mentioned neurodiversity, ADHD, anxiety, OCD, and autism.
Some find class too easy or slow and asked for harder work. Others ask for less work, extension options, or different placement, so balance and choice matter.
-
Students notice how teachers speak to them. They dislike yelling, being called on without volunteering, being put on the spot, and whole-class consequences for one student's behavior. Students say they can tell when a teacher doesn't like them or thinks they're "dumb," and that being discouraged from asking questions shuts down participation. They want respect to go both ways and want teachers to hear their side of the story. One student shared that the best teachers respect students' time and feedback.
-
Many middle schoolers shared that they prefer working on projects with friends or in groups they pick since assigned groups can leave a few students doing the work. Some prefer working alone or quietly. Students asked for input on seating and for several ways to show what they know.
-
Some students said teachers are changing lives, that school is going well, or that their teachers are good at teaching.
Key Themes to “I Wish my teachers knew…”
Suggested Actions
Coordinate homework: Check what other classes assign before setting large tasks, avoid assigning big projects over weekends, and consider a shared calendar of major deadlines to avoid overload..
Make effort visible: Offer clearer rubrics, chances to show understanding in more than one way, and flexibility for students who need extra time or help. Acknowledge effort alongside results.
Welcome questions: Respond to questions with patience so students keep participating. Check in with students who are quiet.
Check in with students: Normalize asking for help and make support options easy to find.
Give time in class. Build in work time so students can ask for help while they work.
Explain the why. Open lessons with how the work connects to real life or current events.
Vary the format. Mix in hands-on, visual, collaborative, and quiet independent work, and offer choices in how students show learning.
Make participation easier. Try think-pair-share or volunteer-first reading rather than calling on students cold.
Post clear directions. Put instructions and examples online so students can review them later.
Offer extension work. Give challenge options to students who finish early, and check whether the pace fits.
Address behavior privately. Avoid whole-class consequences for one student's choices and keep tone respectful.
Be clear and consistent about devices. Share the reasoning behind phone and AI policies, and model the same expectations.
Notice the climate. Respond quickly to bullying and hurtful jokes, and make it easy for students to report concerns.
Check in. Small moments of care, like a greeting or a quick "how are you really?" matter.
Select a topic below to experience the “I Wish” Project
Questions? Email healthyyouth@mercerisland.gov.

